I am also with Progressive (used to be called ASI). My agent is 4cornersinsurance. They should be able to help you.
I just got a letter about my roof yesterday, but fortunately it got replaced in March 2020 because it got damaged by a hurricane so was replaced on the insurance (bit of a cloud with a silver lining) and they are now reinstating it. My renewal is December was $2759 plus $206 for my umbrella $1m liability insurance so I think what they are asking is probably about correct with current increases.