I just want to say, as a non-villa owner, that I would definitley book a villa and not hotels. Apart from maybe a couple of nights in one of the WDW hotels, so that you can "stay in the magic", a villa wins hands down. You will also probably not find much cost difference in renting a four bedroom over a three bedroom and will probably get a better bedroom/space configuration.
One point I would like to make is to also consider renting two cars, even two smaller cars, rather than trying to share one. This will allow for a much greater level of flexibility and also for the group to split up to do separate things.
These are all things that could be booked now and budgeted/paid for over the coming year, so may help spread the cost of the holiday. One other cost to figure in is that you will probably need the pool to be heated in a villa, whch will usually incur a charge at the villa.
Just some thoughts.
Bookmarks