Hi

I can't give you a comparison to the other two resorts you've mentioned as I havent stayed there but I can tell you what we thought of highgrove. We were allocated a villa here when we arrived last year in Orlando so didnt really know what it was going to be like and have to say its a really lovely resort.

Villa we stayed in was nicely decorated, its convenient for Disney and is surrounded by amenities!! We liked it so much we're going back there this year!!