Flight prices have increased dramatically since 2006 & now so many schools are giving a 2 week break in October.
I would shop around over the next week or so & see what happens as others have said prices could come down, they could also go up, not much help I know. BA for one have lots of bridges to mend over the debacle in T5 so you could see reductions on their prices in the coming weeks.
US airways is another airline which flies into Tampa via Charlotte so could be a good route. Alternately try Aer Lingus out of Dublin into Orlando. We got really good prices with Expedia into MCO for May/June so they could be worth a shot. Slightly longer drive to the Gulf coast but as the flights land earlier you get to the villa around the same time as flying into Tampa as the BA flight lands about 5pm.
Good luck with the search.
Lynne
Bookmarks