Hi Vicky, we have also just returned from Calabay Parc (note the C) LOL I wouldn't have thought the difference in the communities distance to an ykey locations would be significant, I would certainly look at what your villa requirements are, pricing and such too Both communities have wonderful homes to choose from Best wishes with your choice. I wouldn't focus your mind on hurricane season too much, I had friends in the area throughout July and some in August last year, no issues at all! [8D]